Penalty Shoot-Outs

Date Opponents Comp Round AET Score Penalty Score U's Goalkeeper Opp. Keeper Pen Takers
07/08/1971 West Bromwich Albion WC Final 4-4 4-2 Graham Smith Jim Cumbes Brian Lewis (s), Brian Gibbs (s (2nd attempt)), Brian Owen (s) Bobby Cram (g), Phil Bloss (s).
30/08/1976 Millwall LC 1st Replay 4-4 2-4 Mick Walker Nicky Johns Bobby Gough (m), Micky Cook (m)
05/09/1979 Aston Villa LC 2nd 2-0 (2-2 on agg) 8-9 Mick Walker Jimmy Rimmer Hodge (s), Allinson (s), Foley (s), Wignall (s), Leslie (s), Dowman (s), Lee (s), Gough (s), Mick Walker (m)
19/01/1988 Leyton Orient SVT 1st 1-1 6-5 Mark Walton Peter Wells Tony English (s), Rudi Hedman (g)
27/11/1991 Exeter City FAC 1st 0-0 2-4 Scott Barrett Kevin Miller McDonough (s), Smith (g), Grainger (s), Kinsella (s)
22/08/1995 Bristol City LC 1st 3-3 4-5 Carl Emberson Keith Welch Simon Betts (m)
20/04/1997 Carlisle United AWS Final 0-0 3-4 Carl Emberson Tony Caig Karl Duguid (m), Peter Cawley (m)
25/11/1997 Brentford FAC 1st 0-0 4-2 Carl Emberson Kevin Dearden David Greene (s), David Gregory (s), Aaron Skelton (s), Simon Betts (s)
06/12/1997 Hereford United FAC 2nd 1-1 4-5 Carl Emberson Andy DeBont Simon Betts (m)
27/11/2001 York City FAC 1st 2-2 2-3 Andy Woodman Alan Fettis Scott McGleish (g), Gavin Johnson (m), Scott Fitzgerals (s), Dean Morgan (s), Karl Duguid (g)
04/11/2003 Yeovil Town AWS 2nd 2-2 4-2 Simon Brown Chris Weale Rowan Vine (s), Scott McGleish (s), Wayne Andrews (s), Joe Keith (s)
28/09/2004 Southend United LDV 1st 1-1 3-5 Aidan Davidson Darryl Flahavon Wayne Brown (m), Joe Keith (s), Kevin Watson (s), Neil Danns (s)
01/09/2009 Gillingham LDV 1st 1-1 3-4 Mark Cousins Alan Julian Scott Vernon (s), Anthony Wordsworth (s), David Fox (g), Matt Lockwood (s), David Perkins (m)
09/08/2011 Wycombe Wanderers LC 1st 3-3 4-5 Mark Cousins Nikki Bull Steven Gillespie (s), Anthony Wordsworth (s), Ian Henderson (s), Lloyd James (s), Michael Rose (g)
08/10/2014 Gillingham JPT 2nd 3-3 2-4 Sam Walker Stuart Nelson Freddie Sears (s), George Moncur (g), Tom Eastman (g), Sean Clohessy (s)
08/11/2016 Charlton Athletic CT Gp S/E 1-1 4-3 Dillon Barnes Dillon Phillips Guthrie (s), Bonne (s), Dunne (g), Dr Wright (s), Slater (s)
g-saved, s-scored, m-missed
United have taken part in 16 penalty shoot-outs. They have won 5, lost 11 scoring 53 penalties and conceding 61.  The success rate is 31.25%